Urban Decay comparison! NAKED palette, UD Loves NYC palette, and The new Anniversary palette!

NAKED PALETTE

From left to right: VIRGIN, SIN, NAKED, SIDECAR, BUCK, HALF BAKED, SMOG, DARKHORSE, TOASTED, HUSTLE, CREEP, GUNMETAL

URBAN DECAY LOVES NYC PALETTE

Top Row from left to right: PRPERVERSION, UZI, LOADED, KUSH

Second row from left to right: MIDNIGHT COWBOY RIDES AGAIN, LAST CALL, ROCKSTAR, MONEY

Third row row from left to right: HAIGHT, MAUI, WOWIE, SMOG, BORDELLO

Fourth row: RADIUM, SNATCH, SUSPECT, PSYCHEDELIC SISTER

15 Year Anniversary palette

Left side from Top to Bottom: MIDNIGHT RODEO, MIDNIGHT 15, VANILLA, FLOW, CHASE

Middle row from Top to Bottom: TAINTED, JUNKSHOW, OMEN, EVIDENCE, DEEP END

Right side from Top to Bottom: DEEPER, M.I.A., ACE, BLACKOUT, HALF TRUTH

These are all of the urban decay palettes I own.  So I can only compare what I have so far.  if you have the naked palette and you are not a color person...there is no need to get this palette.  If you have the NYC palette then yes......you need to get this palette.  The lighter shades in all the palettes are very similar but still different in there own ways.  some has more gold tones some has more champagne undertones.  All shades in the 15 year palette you can kind of dupe in the naked palette and a few in the UD <3's NYC palette.  If you take out the middle row you have another naked palette with slightly different shades.  I swatches from all three palettes to compare.  The photos aren't the best but maybe you can still see the comparison......

The top row is all of the lighters colors in the 15 year palette: MIDNIGHT RODEO, MIDNIGHT 15, VANILLA, FLOW, AND CHASE

The middle swatches are the lighter colors in the NAKED palette: VIRGIN, SIN, AND SIDECAR

The bottom row are the lighter shades in the NYC palette: UZI, MIDNIGHTCOWBOY RIDES AGAIN AND MAUI WOWIE

You can see some of the darker shades are similar as well.  Some may have a little more gold and bronze, and some of the grey/silver shades are slimier. 

The top row is the 15 year palette: DEEPER, M.I.A., ACE

The middle row is the UD NYC palette: SMOG AND SUSPECT

The bottom (if you can see it :-/ ) From the NAKED palette: HALF BAKED, DARK HORSE, HUSTLE, CREEP, AND GUNMETAL

I just wanted to compare the black.  At the top is PERVERSION.  Its a matte black eyeshadow and is a permanent color of Urban Decay.  The Bottom shade is BLACOUT from the 15 year palette.  You can see how much more black it is.  I hope this becomes a permanent color as well.